The Nightmare

The Nightmare, Henry Fuseli, 1782
By CARLY HOFMANN

Despite working during the height of the Enlightenment and the so-called "Age of Reason," Swiss-English painter, Henry Fuseli, instead chose to depict darker, irrational forces in this masterpiece. The Nightmare became an icon of Romanticism and a defining image of Gothic horror.  The painting has yielded many interpretations and is seen as a precursor to late nineteenth-century psychoanalytic theories regarding dreams and the unconscious. The father of psychoanalysis himself, Sigmund Freud, studied this painting and kept a print in his office.

The figure that sits atop the woman's chest is often described as an "imp" or an "incubus." This type of malevolent spirit from germanic legend was believes to lie upon people in their sleep or even have sexual intercourse with sleeping women. The presence of the imp may be understood as a mythic representation of the physical experience of chest pressure during sleep paralysis. Although it is tempting to understand the painting's title as a reference to the horse in the background, the term "nightmare" does not refer to the equine figure. Instead, the name refers to the antiquated term "mara," which refers to an evil spirit that tortured humans by suffocating them in their sleep. It is possible that the milky eyed horse is the evil steed of the mischievous incubus.

Fuseli's painting is suggestive, but not explicit, leaving open the possibility that the woman is simply dreaming. This dream has taken form in a frightening and physical manifestation of the demonic figures. However, the violent slash marks on the drapery suggests that she may have succumbed to the terrors and died. The table top on the left side of the painting holds some mysterious bottles. Perhaps they are perfumes or medicinal concoctions. More than likely, the glasses contain laudanum, a narcotic mixture of alcohol and opium that was popular during Fuseli's time.

Through his use of composition and chiaroscuro the strategic contrasting of light and shadow– Fuseli heightens the drama and uncertainty of his scene. Traditionally, chiaroscuro was used to symbolize the literal enlightening power of rational observation, However, Fuseli's work instead reveals the futility of such light to penetrate and explain the darker realms of the unconscious. The single light source coming from the right, the curtains and tassels in the background, and the shorted foreground all contribute to the theatricality of the work. The red drapery falling off the edge of the bed suggests a river of blood as it might be enacted on stage in the operatic performances of the time.


On the back of the canvas, Fuseli painted an unfinished portrait of a woman. This woman is said to be Anna Landolt, the object of Fuseli's unrequited love during his visit to Switzerland in 1779. After her rejection of Fuseli, his depression and anger manifested itself in his subsequent paintings. This painting has thus been interpreted as an expression of the painter's sexual revenge and frustration. Even the imp's facial features have been seen as resembling Fuseli's own.
  • 7:00 AM

The Nightmare

Fuseli, The Nightmare, 1781

"Last night I had her in bed with me—tossed my bedclothes hugger-mugger—wound my hot and tight-clasped hands about her—fused her body and soul together with my own—poured into her my spirit, breath and strength. Anyone who touches her now commits adultery and incest! She is mine, and I am hers. And have her I will.…" Fuseli might have spoken too soon in the quote from a letter to a friend. He, in fact, had not yet married Anna Landholdt, and this event took place after his proposal to her. The story continues that her family did not approve of Fuseli, and had her married to another man a week later

From his writing we can tell his possessive nature concerning Anna, and because of this some believe she is the back story to this piece. Looking at Fuseli's icon of horror, I see the evil in his work and the sexuality. The imp is set guarding his prey, and the dark horse (or 'mare' from 'nightmare') disturbingly observing the scene. The imp's position of protection leads me to believe that he is a representation of Fuseli according to the backstory, and refusing to let go of Anna as she lies not quite in a state of horror, but one of thrilling ecstasy. Fuseli would like to imagine her happiness with him and being his own, so inside her 'nightmare' she is displayed pleased with the actions bringing about the sexual aspect of Fuseli's vision. 


The woman's elongated figure and illuminated body brings out her emotions and makes Fuseli's composition appealing to look at and allows the viewer to enjoy and begin to understand the story. The light draping along her body and the bed contrasting the thick curtains makes the scene feel intimate, as if I am intruding on a private event.Then again, I also feel like the horse is interrupting as he takes away from the woman and imp, and adds more horror to the piece. All together Fuseli defined horror with The Nightmare when the piece was put out in 1782, and it would be a revolutionary piece in this way for artists.  


  • 7:00 AM

The Nightmare

Henry Fuseli, The Nightmare, 1781

It's eyes. His eyes. Her proportions. The colors. The tones. Even the brush strokes.
That is what the painting has going against it. The title speaks for the painting… a nightmare.

The moment I look at Fuseli’s painting, I am drawn straight to the ape’s eyes. Our irises meet and intertwine in a demented spiral. He sits upon this woman. All the weight of the darkness around him pushes down on her, suppressing all the light within the bottom half of the painting. It provokes an uncomfortable feeling; the words weird and creepy come to mind. Then my eyes meet the horse, which I never find the ability to take seriously with his Ping-Pong eyeballs and his head erupting from the curtains from nothingness.

To further place the viewer into a state of discomfort, the painting carries a sexual sense to it. The woman lies in a vulnerable position, with her arms adding a possibility of sex. Within this floating around in my head, the idea that this scene becomes more disturbing. This horrid creature, hunched over, just sitting on top her as he stares at you. He knows you’re looking at him. I feel as if I have just walked into a room, interrupting his thoughts. His eyebrows and frown form an expression of hate. Not necessarily to the viewer, but at himself. What he is or has become.

I dislike Fuseli’s painting because I cannot help but feel like the product was a failed attempt. I look at the work and see an idea Fuseli was tackling. He has produced this scene to represent a disturbing setting, a nightmare. In a physiological sense, the work depicts the mind in an unconscious state and we’re seeing a glimpse at her dreams. While this is a cool concept to capture, I think he falls short in the simplicity of it. To make the subject as simple as he did and have the proportions be off, the idea falls through.

Before setting paint to this canvas, Fuseli’s proposal of marriage had been rejected by the father of an Anna Landholdt in Zürich. It is believed that this composition, which he has done three different variations, was a direct result to this denial. In the end this happens to be his most well known work. Having never commented on the painting, we can only see what feelings and emotions he decided to share with us on the canvas, which left contemporary critics speculating.
  • 7:00 AM